What did CeraVe actually buy at the Super Bowl?
In January 2024, a rumor started moving around the internet that the actor Michael Cera had founded CeraVe. The evidence was thin: he shares part of the name, and he has unusually soft skin. Influencers fed the story, pop culture sites picked it up, and CeraVe’s own social accounts began to deny it. Then dermatologists on TikTok joined in to argue with him.
The whole thing was planned. CeraVe and its agency, Ogilvy PR, had spent weeks building a fake conspiracy that ended with the brand’s first Super Bowl ad.1 In the ad, Cera’s claim is shut down by a boardroom of CeraVe dermatologists, and the closing line reads: developed with dermatologists, not Michael Cera.4
The agency’s awards entry explains the problem they were solving. Super Bowl audiences want celebrities and comedy, and a straight campaign about dermatologists and ceramides would have been ignored.3 So they used a celebrity to get attention and gave the dermatologists the final word. The campaign generated 32 billion earned impressions against a goal of 1 billion, and CeraVe reports that it led to the highest one-week moisturizer sales in the brand’s history.2
I’ve spent most of my career on the other side of this problem. DOT I/O Health, the data and insight business I founded, works with pharma companies and is now part of Adelo as our in-house agency. Its work starts with the audience: who they are, where they live, how they behave and who they listen to. CeraVe split those two jobs cleanly. Michael Cera got people to look, and the dermatologists gave them a reason to buy.
That split is now playing out across beauty, wellness and consumer health. The question for every brand is how to do both, and what to do with the trust once they’ve earned it.
earned impressions for CeraVe’s Super Bowl campaign, against a 1bn goal (Cannes Lions entry)
of women trust dermatologists or doctors most for skincare advice, vs influencers (Avon, 2024)
rise in CeraVe cleanser sales in the week of a live dermatologist panel (PRWeek)
of US beauty sales on TikTok come through live streams (McKinsey, 2026)
Why has expertise moved from the store to the feed?
People have always wanted someone to tell them what works. For decades in beauty, that person stood behind a department store counter. McKinsey’s beauty team discussed this on a recent episode of The McKinsey Podcast. Alexis Wolfer, who leads the firm’s North America beauty practice, pointed out that counters are organized by brand and usually staffed by that brand’s salespeople, so to get expert advice you first have to pick the brand.5
Shoppers don’t buy that way anymore. Wolfer says they mix brands, price points and retailers in a single routine, so they want guidance that isn’t tied to one label. They have found it on platforms like TikTok, where, in her words, the expert is often “an influencer a couple of doors, towns, or countries away.”5
Many of the most effective of those influencers are trained professionals. Dermatologists, cosmetic chemists and dietitians have built followings by explaining science in plain language, and the trust data explains why. In a 2024 Avon survey of more than 7,000 women in seven countries, 60% named a dermatologist or doctor, in person or online, as the source they trust most for skincare advice. Only 5% named social media influencers.7
Who women trust most for skincare advice
Share of 7,172 women in seven countries naming each as the source they trust most for skincare advice. Dermatologists or doctors: 36% in person, 24% online. Survey by Censuswide for Avon, March 2024.7
Brands founded by doctors show the same pattern. Research by Glossy and Launchmetrics found that while celebrity-founded brands took most of the media attention, doctor-founded skincare brands such as Murad and Dr. Dennis Gross stayed relevant, helped by their founders’ own growing followings on social media. Dermatologist-founded 111Skin reported an 84% rise in sales year on year in the first quarter of 2021.22
Trust in general has also become more spread out. In Edelman’s 2024 Trust Barometer, people trusted scientists and “someone like me” equally, at 74% each, to tell the truth about new innovations.8 The person people believe now is a credible expert who also feels close to them, which is a fair description of the best dermatologists on TikTok.
Can a celebrity tell people a product works?
Marketing researchers have studied this for more than 30 years. In 1990, Michael Kamins published a study testing what became known as the match-up hypothesis. He paired an attractive celebrity, Tom Selleck, and a less conventionally attractive one, Telly Savalas, with two products: a luxury car and a home computer. The attractive celebrity improved how people rated the car and the ad. For the computer, his looks made no difference.9
Later research found the same pattern from the other side. In a 2006 study by Biswas, Biswas and Das, expert endorsers did more than celebrities to reduce people’s sense of risk about high-technology products.10 A famous face helps when the product is about image and status. When the product makes a claim about how it works, such as what an ingredient does to your skin or whether a supplement is safe, people want expertise.
Consumers say much the same thing. In a 2024 survey of 3,000 US adults, commissioned by Casino.org, 60.7% said they trust brands less when they use celebrity endorsements, and 81.8% said celebrity brand deals lack credibility.11 Beauty was one of the more accepting categories, ranking third for celebrity approval behind fashion and music, which fits Kamins’ finding: people will take a celebrity’s word on how something looks far more readily than on whether it works.
Celebrities still have a job to do. An exchange4media analysis of Indian skincare marketing found that brands still rely on them for reach, recall and cultural relevance, especially at launch.13 A celebrity can still tell people a product works, as long as an expert is there to back it up.
The simplest version is a celebrity pointing to an expert: “my dermatologist told me.” It works, but it keeps the expert offstage. The stronger version puts them in the same event, such as a webinar or live panel. The celebrity takes the part of the user. They talk about how they use the product, ask the questions the audience would ask and admit what they weren’t sure about. The expert supplies the science: what the ingredients do, who the product suits and who should avoid it. The celebrity brings the audience into the room, and the expert gives that audience a reason to believe.
The celebrity plays the user, the expert supplies the science, and the audience watches them together
Adelo illustration. The example lines are illustrative.
The people watching see more than an endorsement. They see a family around the brand: a user they recognize, and a professional who stands behind what that user says. Because the audience hears the expert answer the celebrity directly, they believe the claim in a way they wouldn’t if either person made it alone. CeraVe’s Super Bowl ad used a version of this. Michael Cera made the claim, and the dermatologists in the same room settled it.
Research on campaigns with more than one endorser supports this. Anna von Felbert and Christoph Breuer tested combinations of celebrity endorsers for a sports product and found that using several endorsers increased purchase intention overall, and that each endorser’s fit with the product decided how much they added.14 Earlier work found that once people see an endorser as an expert, their other qualities, such as looks or fame, matter much less. In a family of voices, the expert is the one whose credibility everyone else draws on.
I think there is something more here, and it is a hypothesis I’m still exploring. Most brands work with endorsers who never meet. A celebrity fronts the ad campaign, a dermatologist appears in a separate video and an influencer posts on their own channel, and none of them ever refers to the others. CeraVe worked because its voices were connected. The dermatologists answered Michael Cera directly, and the TikTok creators joined the same story.
Film studios understand this better than most marketers. Marvel built a cinematic universe in which characters cross into each other’s films, and a 2022 study of 250 films released between 2009 and 2019 found that belonging to the Marvel Cinematic Universe had a significant effect on box office receipts.23 Parrot Analytics found that crossover episodes raised demand for the TV shows involved by an average of 12%, with the smallest gains when the shows weren’t part of the same universe.24
Advertising research points the same way. A 2020 study of campaigns using several celebrities found that how well the endorsers fit with each other, as well as with the brand, improved people’s attitudes toward the ad.25 My view is that a brand’s endorsers work best when they belong to the same universe: they know each other, refer to each other and appear together, so the audience sees one family around the brand.
What does pharma know about opinion leaders that consumer brands don’t?
Pharma learned this lesson a long time ago, mostly because regulation forced it to. Pharma companies can’t hire a celebrity to say a drug works, so they built their influence around physicians. Key opinion leader management has been standard practice in life sciences for decades: companies identify the doctors other doctors look to, and work with them on research, education and speaking.15
When social media arrived, pharma adapted. By 2014, the industry was writing about digital opinion leaders, physicians whose influence comes from online audiences more than journal papers.16 Finding them is now a discipline of its own. Analysts map the online communities around a condition, profile the professionals inside them and check who actually shapes the conversation, a process the industry calls influence mapping.15
This is where every DOT I/O Health project begins. Before you can choose who should speak, you need to know who is listening: their life stage, where they live, what shapes their health decisions and which voices they already trust. Two people buying the same menopause supplement can have very different questions and very different people they believe. A national academic will reach one of them. A local practitioner, or a peer with the same experience, will reach the other.
Most consumer brands still skip that step. They choose experts by follower count, or by who is available. A few are starting to work like pharma. Pierre Fabre Laboratories, which owns Avène, built a benchmark dashboard that tracks healthcare professional creators only, so its team can see which experts actually move its audience and which partnerships to grow. The company now treats that data-led approach as its standard.17
What happens when a brand borrows an expert’s trust carelessly?
An expert’s credibility is valuable, and that makes it easy to abuse. In 2023, The Washington Post and the nonprofit newsroom The Examination looked at 68 registered dietitians with large social followings. About half had been paid in the previous year to promote foods, drinks or supplements. One beverage trade group paid ten dietitians, a physician and a fitness influencer to push back on the World Health Organization’s warnings about aspartame, and many of the posts did not clearly say who had paid for them.18 The Federal Trade Commission later sent warnings to two industry groups and a dozen influencers.19
The rules have tightened as well. The FTC’s updated Endorsement Guides, in force since July 2023, hold expert endorsers to a higher standard. An expert must have the expertise the ad says they have, and must actually use it to evaluate the product, as thoroughly as someone with the same training normally would.20
For brands this cuts both ways. Experts have more influence than celebrities, and they also bear more responsibility. A brand that works with experts needs to know what each one said, in what context, and with what disclosure. A clip on a creator’s account doesn’t give it that.
Where does the trust go when the event ends?
Look again at CeraVe. In 2022, before the Super Bowl, the brand ran a live TikTok event called Cleanse Like a Derm. Dermatologist Dr. Dustin Portela, who has more than 2 million TikTok followers, moderated a panel with fellow dermatologist Dr. Michelle Henry and makeup artist Avani Gregg, who has more than 42 million followers. Sales of CeraVe’s core cleansers that week were up more than 52% on the same week a year earlier.21
CeraVe’s cleanser sales rose more than 52% in the week it put dermatologists and a creator on one live panel.Campaign / PRWeek, on “Cleanse Like a Derm,” 2022
That event is a webinar in everything but name: a moderator, an expert panel, a live audience and questions from the floor. It is also the family from section 03 on a single stage. Gregg’s following brought the audience, and the dermatologists gave it answers worth staying for. McKinsey’s 2026 beauty report shows how much of the market now runs this way. Live streaming accounts for about 22% of US beauty sales on TikTok, and 49% of live stream viewers say they watch to see products in action, with reviews and testimonials.6
A hosted event with an expert panel and questions from the audience

Adelo platform, demo workspace. A host and a three-person panel, with anonymous audience questions answered during the event.
What happens afterward matters as much as the event. When the event ends, the recording sits on a platform the brand doesn’t control, often on the creator’s account. The brand has no transcript it owns, no record of which answers held the audience’s attention, and no easy way to find what the dermatologist said about cleansing when a customer asks the same question six months later.
That gap is about to matter more. McKinsey’s report advises brands to structure product content around clinical validation so that AI systems can interpret and recommend it.6 People increasingly ask an AI assistant which product to use. A dermatologist explaining who a cleanser suits, and who should avoid it, is the kind of clear, clinical answer those systems look for. It only helps the brand if the brand has kept it, with the transcript, the context and the consent attached.
Celebrities will keep bringing people to brands, and they should, but the expert’s answer is the part that keeps its value long after the campaign ends. The brands that come out ahead will treat every event with a celebrity and an expert as part of a record they own: searchable, compliant and ready to answer the next person’s question.
Frequently asked questions
Should brands use celebrities or experts?
Most brands need both, because they do different jobs. Celebrities and large creators bring reach and attention. Experts such as dermatologists, dietitians and pharmacists make people believe a product works. The strongest approach puts them in the same webinar or live event, with the celebrity as the user and the expert supplying the science, so the audience sees a family around the brand and believes it.
Can a celebrity make a claim about whether a product works?
Yes, when an expert stands behind it. Pointing to an expert helps, as in “my dermatologist told me,” but it works best when the two appear together and the expert answers the celebrity’s questions directly. Research on campaigns with more than one endorser finds that multiple endorsers can increase purchase intention when each one fits the product.
Do consumers trust dermatologists more than influencers?
For skincare advice, yes. In a 2024 Avon survey of more than 7,000 women in seven countries, 60% named a dermatologist or doctor, in person or online, as the source they trust most for skincare advice, compared with 5% for social media influencers.
What is a digital opinion leader?
A digital opinion leader is a health professional whose influence comes mainly from online audiences, on social media, podcasts or video, rather than from journals and conferences. Pharma companies have mapped and worked with digital opinion leaders for more than a decade.
What are the FTC rules for expert endorsements?
Under the FTC’s Endorsement Guides, updated in 2023, an expert in an ad must have the expertise they are presented as having, and must actually use it to evaluate the product. Paid relationships must be clearly disclosed.
How do you choose the right expert for a brand?
Start with your audience: who they are, what shapes their decisions and which voices they already trust. Then look for experts who combine relevant credentials with an audience that overlaps yours, and check conflicts of interest and how they come across on camera.
Sources
- Ogilvy. Michael CeraVe. Campaign case study, 2024.
- Cannes Lions (2024). Michael CeraVe, Social and Influencer: Creator and Influencer Marketing. Results as reported by the entrant.
- Cannes Lions (2024). Michael CeraVe, Entertainment: Community.
- CeraVe (2024). CeraVe collaborates with Michael Cera and TikTok stars on first-of-its-kind global campaign. PR Newswire via AAP, 12 February 2024.
- McKinsey & Company (2026). Beauty, redefined. The McKinsey Podcast, with Alexis Wolfer and Sara Hudson, November 2026.
- McKinsey & Company (2026). From aisle to algorithm: The beauty categories, channels, and concepts shaping 2030 growth. June 2026.
- Avon (2024). Future of Beauty Report: Skincare Edition. Censuswide survey of 7,172 women in the UK, Italy, Poland, Turkey, South Africa, the Philippines and Romania, March 2024. Reported by Cosmetics Design Europe and BeautyMatter.
- Edelman (2024). 2024 Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report. Trust to tell the truth about new innovations and technologies.
- Kamins, M. A. (1990). An investigation into the “match-up” hypothesis in celebrity advertising: When beauty may be only skin deep. Journal of Advertising, 19(1), 4–13.
- Biswas, D., Biswas, A. and Das, N. (2006). The differential effects of celebrity and expert endorsements on consumer risk perceptions. Journal of Advertising, 35(2), 17–31. Author manuscript.
- Agility PR (2024). Do consumers trust celebrity endorsements anymore? On a Casino.org survey of 3,000 US adults, 27 February 2024.
- BBB National Programs (2025). The 2025 Influencer Trust Index. National Advertising Division with The Benchmarking Company, 3,700+ US consumers.
- exchange4media. Science over stardom? Skincare brands are changing the face of beauty marketing.
- von Felbert, A. and Breuer, C. (2022). The influence of multiple combinations of celebrity endorsers on consumers’ intentions to purchase a sports-related product. Sport, Business and Management. Includes the review of Mowen and Brown (1981).
- Pharmaceutical Commerce. Defining digital opinion leaders in healthcare.
- pharmaphorum (2014). KOL engagement: Authority and influence in a digital world. September 2014.
- Traackr. Pierre Fabre Laboratories USA case study.
- The Washington Post and The Examination (2023). The food industry pays influencer dietitians to shape your eating habits. Republished by Anchorage Daily News, 17 September 2023.
- The Examination (2023). US regulator cracks down on food industry for paid dietitian “influencer” posts.
- Arnold & Porter (2023). FTC signals continued heightened scrutiny of endorsements with final rule adopting revised Endorsement Guides. 7 July 2023.
- Campaign / PRWeek (2022). CeraVe global TikTok Live event leads to increase in sales.
- Glossy (2023). Glossy x Launchmetrics research: The buzziest doctor-founded skin-care brands. 9 January 2023.
- Applied Economics (2022). Study of cinematic universes and box office receipts, using 250 films released 2009–2019. DOI 10.1080/00036846.2022.2038775.
- Parrot Analytics. The crossover effect.
- Um, N. (2020). Factors predicting the effectiveness of multiple celebrity endorsement. Via KoreaScience.





